Find a business

        Saved to Favorites

        thumbnail

        Pie In The Sky Pizzeria

        Add to Favorites
        Claimed
        $
        Restaurants, Pizza
        (4)
        OPEN NOW
        Today: 1:00 pm - 8:00 pm
        Years in Business icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        (540) 948-4001CallVisit WebsiteVisit WebsiteMap & DirectionsDirections312 N Main StMadison, VA 22727Write a ReviewWrite Review

        Reviews

        Hi there!
        Rate this business!
        What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
        Click to Rate
        GG
        G G.

        03/06/2018

        Overall
        Atmosphere
        Food
        Service

        Good pizza at a good price. Can be a little slow at peak times, otherwise best in town. Fries are good, but overpriced. Loved the fried mushrooms.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        madisonpatriot

        12/31/2012

        Overall
        These are new owners and seem ...

        These are new owners and seem more concerned about what they like than what the customers like. They have made changes from the GREAT service and menu that Two Brothers had. The changes we see are mostly NOT for the better ! It is still a good place to eat because of the manager and staff, but the owners need to listen to feedback from customers.

        Helpful(0)Flag
        flmom61

        05/12/2009

        Overall
        New owners have turned the place around

        Since the change of owners in april of 2008 the food has been outstanding. Hand thrown pizza and fresh salads are great. Plan ahead for Friday nights. At times waits can be as much as an hour, but so worth the wait. Call ahead for dine in and the pizza will be ready, fresh and hot when you get there. You will want to return soon.

        Helpful(0)Flag

        Details

        Phone: (540) 948-4001

        Address: 312 N Main St, Madison, VA 22727

        Website: Pie in the Sky Pizzeria

        More Info

        Old Favorites, New Flavors

        General Info
        Our pizza is made using only high-quality ingredients from start to finish. We start with freshly made dough, never frozen, and cold proofed like in bread bakeries, or as with Champagnes or beers, allowing the flavors to develop. The dough is sealed with a layer of rich olive oil. The secret is also in the sauce—our pizza sauce is made of Italian Pear Tomatoes, fresh packed at the fields at the peak of ripeness and never frozen; olive oil; and a combination of spices. We use our own mix of cheeses, shredded and blended for the best in flavor and freshness. Lastly, we slice and chop our fruits, vegetables, and meats to ensure the highest quality experience for our customers. That’s how we do pizza.
        Services/Products
        Pie in the Sky is a restaurant in Madison, VA. We use exceptional ingredients with artisan craftsmanship to serve you fun, great tasting food! Pizza, Pasta, Subs, Sandwiches, wings, apps, beer and wine.
        Payment method
        amex, all major credit cards, visa, mastercard, discover
        Price Range
        $
        Location
        Near corner of Washington and North Main Street
        Other Link

        Pie in the Sky Pizzeria

        Categories
        Restaurants, Pizza
        Other Information

        Cuisines: Pizza

        People Also Viewed